At first it seemed really good, and the cat likes it too, but lately the beef and lamb have a very strange, bitter smell. The cat doesn’t seem to mind, but I’d rather switch to something else. No problems with the other flavours (so far the fish and chicken have both been fine).
Even though it's very runny, my cats didn't like it at all... they just licked a bit and that's it. The smell doesn't attract them, even though they usually love broths.